amazon Amazon Echo Blog Echo echo alternativen Gadgets Technik Test

Alternatives for Echo: Seven alternatives to Amazon's echo models in the test

Christoph Lumetzberger
three June 2019

Seven alternatives to Amazon's echo models in the test

Whether Amazon has anticipated such a powerful success when the first Echo models have been introduced, is just not recognized. The very fact is, nevertheless, that the bill labored perfectly: Amazon at present holds about 65 % of the market share in the “smart speaker” sector and is thus nicely ahead of Google (with “Home”) and Apple with the Homepod. “Alexa” made its debut in tens of millions of houses during the 2018 Christmas week alone.

Nevertheless, if you’d like to all the time know the sensible woman in your area, you would not have to make any representations to Amazon. The web big has released “Alexa” or the interface for third-party vendors, which signifies that any producer of audio system can theoretically equip its merchandise with voice management. A sensible transfer, in any case, Amazon needs to obtain as high as potential market penetration. Whether Alexa is sitting in considered one of the in-house echo models or in the speaker of one other manufacturer just isn’t actually essential for Amazon.

Countless providers

Such products can now be discovered on the Web abound, by well-known and lesser-known manufacturers alike. With Sonos, a world-famous firm jumped on the Alexa practice. We requested for a total of seven “Smart Speakers” for comparison and subsequently reveal whether the third social gathering distributors are nearly as good as the originals.

Improve as an alternative of buying new

There’s an alternate risk: The Echo Dot has an AUX output and a Bluetooth interface. In other phrases, if you already have a “stupid” speaker, you possibly can shortly connect it to the Echo Dot. As quickly as you arrange the echo, the app will ask you if you need to pair a loudspeaker. You simply dial, whether or not by way of Bluetooth or with the cable, and then continue the setup as regular. We examined it with a Teufel loudspeaker, the “Boomster”. The decor was not an issue, the sound logically good. The one catch: you’ve gotten to flip the speaker on and off manually. In other words, if you’d like a track from Alexa, however the speaker just isn’t turned on and related, you'll hear over the dot again. In return, you’ll be able to place the speaker and the echo dot independently, at the least within a radius of about ten meters.

Necessary commands:

  • “Alexa, connect with my smartphone.”
  • “Alexa, how is the weather going to be in Berlin today?”
  • “Alexa, put milk on my grocery list.”

You possibly can talk with the echo alternatives introduced here as well as with the unique Amazon units.

MOTOROLA – Sonic Increase 210

The 8 x 3.5 x 8 cm and 118 gram Bluetooth speaker matches perfectly in any pocket and delivers a surprisingly good sound. A full battery charge of the useful companion is adequate for about 4 hours of music playback. Using the built-in microphone, the Sonic Increase 210 can be used as a hands-free system and even Alexa is supported. Play music, ask questions, make calls – something is possible. Simply ask.

Worth: 24.99 EUR / Voice management: Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Siri / Battery life: four hours / Particular function: Rechargeable battery by way of any USB port / connection: AUX / bit.ly/moto210

+ Surprisingly good sound regardless of its small case, the AUX connection and the capacity to use Alexa on the go.
In fact, the compact speaker in terms of sound cannot sustain with its wired, huge brothers. In addition, the Bluetooth range is weak.

Score: GOOD

AUVISIO – QAS-400

For about 70 euros the mail order firm Pearl presents this sensible speaker. Nice to take a look at is the LED bar above, which may mild up in totally different colors. General, the QAS-400, nevertheless, is stored quite easy, the manufacturer relies on a basic cuboid form and plastic. In view of the worth, the sound high quality is okay, but there’s a respectful distance to the prime class. The Alexa integration works perfectly.

Worth: 63,90 EUR / Output power: 2 x 5 watts I Music prime performance: 20 watts / Voice control: Amazon Alexa / Streaming: Amazon Music, Pandora, Spotify, TuneIn / Extras: Multiroom perform / bit.ly/sm_qas

+ Easy type, very reasonable worth, useful gear: The Auvisio speaker provides itself as a cheap various for newcomers.
There are weaknesses in the sound, in addition, the microphones are weaker than the unique echo. Meaning Alexa doesn’t all the time perceive every command.

Score: GOOD

SONOS – ONE

Anybody who likes robust, room-filling sound is wonderfully advised with these speakers. The Sonos One may be paired, together with with the Sonos Beam (test on web page 76). The sound is beyond a single speaker beyond any doubt, Sonos convinces right here with the traditional outstanding quality. The Alexa integration allows the widespread instructions resembling the music management and the operation of the sensible house.

Worth: 229 EUR / Voice Control: Amazon Alexa / Various: Buttons, App / Connectivity: Wi-Fi, Ethernet, AirPlay (2), Apple Music, Spotify, Amazon Music, Audible, Deezer / Extras: Multiroom perform, moisture resistant / bit.ly / one-sonos

+ Wonderful sound, numerous extras plus the risk to couple several audio system: The Sonos system is dear, but in addition excellent. – Troublesome to discover one thing here. The worth is in fact high, the app a bit awkward. Nevertheless, there’s nothing more to criticize.

Score: VERY GOOD

AUNA INTELLIGENCE – DAB + kitchen radio

The sensible kitchen radio might be effortlessly mounted beneath kitchen cupboards and racks with the included base gadget. With the built-in DAB + and FM antenna and the TuneIn streaming service, you’ll be able to receive digital radio in addition to analog radio stations and hundreds of stations from throughout the world. Thanks to Alexa voice management, the whole world of sensible language assistant can also be obtainable in the kitchen.

Worth: 69,99 EUR / Voice control: Alexa / Connectivity: WLAN, Bluetooth, DLNA / Extras: Multiroom perform, LCD display, DAB + Perform / Output energy: 5 Watt /
Colors: white, silver / bit.ly/auna-radio

+ Many various modes make the radio a perfect all-rounder. The assembly is straightforward and the workmanship is completely okay for the worth. – The voice control nonetheless has room for enchancment. Alexa typically had a tough time understanding the instructions. Typically she even answered without warning.

Score: GOOD

MEDION – Life P91110

Medion, recognized above all from the food retail commerce, additionally has a sensible speaker in its portfolio. The identify isn’t very nice, the speaker, nevertheless, already. Medion was very comparable to the unique and decided accordingly for a tubular form. On the aspect, nevertheless, some keys are put in, which ought to simplify the operation. An AUX slot can also be put in. The sound is okay, however worse than the unique echo.

Worth: 99.95 EUR / Voice management: Amazon Alexa / Connectivity: WLAN, Bluetooth, jack cable, DLNA / Extras: Multiroom perform, far-field speech recognition / Output energy: 5 watts / rechargeable battery: 2.500 mAh / bit.ly/medion-box

+ Constructed-in battery with useful operating time, affordable worth and quite good sound – a strong various to the basic echo.
The 2 microphones typically have hassle understanding commands. The sound high quality can also be weaker compared to the echo.

Score: GOOD

HAMA – SIRIUM 1400

Instantly unpacking the Hama Sirium 1400 you’ll discover the impeccable workmanship and the high-quality materials. So the sensible speaker is visually a real various for Amazon's Echo. The buttons have a great strain point and the cumbersome look of the Sirium seems to be very noble. Plus, the speaker also gets the built-in multiroom function, which permits you to play the similar music on multiple audio system at the similar time.

Worth: 149 EUR / Speaker: 20 Watt I Voice Management: Amazon Alexa / Management by way of: Remote Management, App / Extras:
Multiroom perform, alternatively music by way of Bluetooth / bit.ly/hamasirium

+ The processing of the speaker could be very interesting, music can be played by way of Bluetooth. Plus also for the multi-room perform.
Sadly, whereas the sound is alright, the Sirium 1400 is a bit off the bass, and the audio system do not all the time understand the spoken phrase.

Score: GOOD

LENOVO – SMART ASSISTANT

At first glance, the Sensible Assistant from Lenovo is harking back to an Echo Plus. Even when using are initially no deviations from the sensible speaker from Amazon to acknowledge. It only takes a re-evaluation to see that Amazon Lenovo uses the Alexa Voice system, however with some limitations. It lacks a few multiroom perform or the capacity to name different echo speakers. When it comes to sound and design, there’s nothing to moan about.

Worth: 94,99 EUR / Voice management: Amazon Alexa / Various: Buttons, App / Speaker: 15 Watt / Extras: Set off button and volume control on the speaker / Colours: Grey, Black, Orange, Blue / bit.ly/lenovosmartassistant

+ The Sensible Assistant is completely spectacular in terms of sound and design, and the workmanship can also be profitable. Worth / performance are okay. – Sadly, the Lenovo Sensible Assistant lacks one or the other Alexa function, resembling multiroom or the means to call different echoes.

Score: GOOD

Motorola_Sonic Boost 210

MOTOROLA – Sonic Increase 210

The eight x three.5 x 8 cm and 118 gram Bluetooth speaker matches perfectly in any pocket and delivers a surprisingly good sound. A full battery cost of the useful companion is adequate for about 4 hours of music playback. Utilizing the built-in microphone, the Sonic Increase 210 can be used as a hands-free system and even Alexa is supported. Play music, ask questions, make calls – anything is feasible. Simply ask.

Worth: 24.99 EUR / Voice management: Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Siri / Battery life: 4 hours / Particular function: Rechargeable battery by way of any USB port / connection: AUX /
bit.ly/moto210

+ Surprisingly good sound despite the small case, the AUX connection and the risk to use Alexa on the go.

– In fact, the compact speaker in phrases of sound cannot sustain together with his wired, massive brothers. In addition, the Bluetooth range is weak.

Score: GOOD

Auvisio QAS-400

AUVISIO – QAS-400

For about 70 euros the mail order firm Pearl gives this sensible speaker. Good to take a look at is the LED bar above, which may mild up in totally different colors. General, the QAS-400, nevertheless, is stored quite simple, the manufacturer relies on a basic cuboid shape and plastic. In view of the worth, the sound high quality is okay, but there’s a respectful distance to the prime class. The Alexa integration works completely.

Worth: 63,90 EUR / Output energy: 2 x 5 Watt I Music prime performance: 20 Watts / Voice control: Amazon Alexa / Streaming: Amazon Music, Pandora, Spotify, TuneIn / Extras:
Multiroom perform / bit.ly/sm_qas

+ Simple type, very reasonable worth, usable gear: The Auvisio speaker provides itself as a reasonable various for learners.

– There are weaknesses in the sound, in addition, the microphones are weaker than the unique echo. Meaning Alexa does not all the time understand every command.

Score: GOOD

Sonos ONE

SONOS – ONE

Anybody who likes robust, room-filling sound is wonderfully suggested with these audio system. The Sonos One might be paired, together with with the Sonos Beam (test on page 76). The sound is past a single speaker beyond any doubt, Sonos convinces right here with the standard excellent quality. The Alexa integration permits the widespread commands resembling the music management and the operation of the sensible residence.

Worth: 229 EUR / Voice Control: Amazon Alexa / Various: Buttons, App / Connectivity: Wi-Fi, Ethernet, AirPlay (2), Apple Music, Spotify, Amazon Music, Audible, Deezer / Extras: Multiroom perform, moisture resistant / bit.ly / one-sonos

+ Wonderful sound, plenty of extras plus the means to pair multiple speakers: The Sonos system is dear, but in addition excellent.

– Troublesome to find one thing here. The worth is in fact excessive, the app a bit awkward. Nevertheless, there’s nothing more to criticize.

Score: VERY GOOD

Auna Intelligence DAB + kitchen radio

AUNA INTELLIGENCE – DAB + kitchen radio

The sensible kitchen radio could be effortlessly mounted beneath kitchen cabinets and racks with the included base system. With the built-in DAB + and FM antenna and the TuneIn streaming service, you possibly can receive digital radio in addition to analog radio stations and hundreds of stations from throughout the world. Thanks to Alexa voice management, the whole world of sensible language assistant can also be obtainable in the kitchen.

Worth: 69,99 EUR / Voice control: Alexa / Connectivity: WLAN, Bluetooth, DLNA / Extras: Multiroom perform, LCD display, DAB + Perform / Output energy: 5 Watt /
Colors: white, silver / bit.ly/auna-radio

+ Many various modes make the radio an ideal all-rounder. The meeting is straightforward and the workmanship is completely okay for the worth.

– The voice management still has room for improvement. Alexa typically had a hard time understanding the instructions. Typically she even answered with out warning.

Score: GOOD

Medion Life P61110

MEDION – Life P61110

Medion, recognized above all from the meals retail commerce, also has a sensible speaker in its portfolio. The identify is just not very good, the speaker, nevertheless, already. Medion was very comparable to the unique and decided accordingly for a tubular form. On the aspect, nevertheless, some keys are installed, which ought to simplify the operation. An AUX slot can also be installed. The sound is okay, however worse than the unique echo.

Worth: 99.95 EUR / Voice management: Amazon Alexa / Connectivity: WLAN, Bluetooth, jack cable, DLNA / Extras: Multiroom perform, far-field speech recognition / Output energy: 5 watts / rechargeable battery: 2.500 mAh / bit.ly/medion-box

+ Constructed-in battery with useful operating time, affordable worth and fairly good sound – a strong various to the basic echo.

– The 2 microphones typically have problem understanding commands. The sound high quality can also be weaker in contrast to the echo.

Score: GOOD

Hama Sirium 1400

HAMA – SIRIUM 1400

Immediately unpacking the Hama Sirium 1400 you’ll notice the impeccable workmanship and the high-quality materials. So the sensible speaker is visually a real various for Amazon's Echo. The buttons have a superb strain point and the bulky look of the Sirium seems very noble. Plus, the speaker also will get the built-in multiroom function, which permits you to play the similar music on multiple audio system at the similar time.

Worth: 149 EUR / Speaker: 20 Watt I Voice Management: Amazon Alexa / Management by way of: Distant Management, App / Extras:
Multiroom perform, alternatively music by way of Bluetooth / bit.ly/hamasirium

+ The processing of the speaker could be very appealing, music can be played by way of Bluetooth. Plus additionally for the multi-room perform.

– Whereas the sound is alright, the Sirium 1400 falls a bit lower on the bass, moreover, the speakers do not all the time understand the spoken phrase.

Score: Good

Lenovo Smart Assistant

LENOVO – SMART ASSISTANT

At first look, the Sensible Assistant from Lenovo is harking back to an Echo Plus. Even when using are initially no deviations from the sensible speaker from Amazon to recognize. It only takes a re-evaluation to see that Amazon Lenovo uses the Alexa Voice system, but with some limitations. It lacks a few multiroom perform or the capability to name different echo audio system. When it comes to sound and design, there’s nothing to moan about.

Worth: 94,99 EUR / Voice management: Amazon Alexa / Various: Buttons, App / Speaker: 15 Watt / Extras: Set off button and quantity management on the speaker / Colours: Gray, Black, Orange, Blue / bit.ly/lenovosmartassistant

+ The Sensible Assistant can sound and design absolutely convincing, additionally the processing is profitable. Worth / efficiency are okay.

– Unfortunately, the Lenovo Sensible Assistant lacks one or the different Alexa function, akin to multiroom or the capability to call other echoes.

Score: Good

Conclusion

Our test exhibits one thing very clearly: it isn’t vital to buy the Echo models in order to get the absolute best outcome. Amazon offers the software program and makes positive that Alexa all the time is aware of what to do. But that doesn’t imply that your personal hardware options are necessarily the greatest. The worth speaks in favor of the trial purchase of an Echo Dots, especially since it may also be combined with an present sound infrastructure. The sound of the Sonos One, for example, is best than that of the Echo models. The award for the greatest sound will get the US-American specialist superior, to that there was no dialogue in the editorship. Sonos, nevertheless, can also be significantly costlier than the competition.

With Clazio, the entire system is fascinating, however the “Spark Voice” continues to be scuffling with teething issues. The products of Medion or auvisio are a lot better, all three ran with out problems from the beginning.

Who needs good sound from a system, ought to resort to Sonos. Anyone who does not want to dig too deep into the pockets is nicely advised with Medion or Auvisio, with the Echo Dot as nicely. Nevertheless, we additionally assume that in the close to future more manufacturers will report with a sensible speaker – remains to be seen whether the degree remains so persistently high.